Vegan Myths: Vegans live longer
Written by Keira Edwards-Huolohan
Created Monday, 03 February 2014
It would be nice if that were true I guess. It's something that I've seen repeated a lot by both vegetarians and vegans, as well as on some 'green living' websites.
Most of what I've seen said online seems to be based on a study by Fraser (1999). In this study, vegetarian Seventh-day Adventists were found to live about 2.5-3.2 years longer than their non-vegetarian counterparts. This study is not the only one to show such a link. A meta-analysis of 7 studies found that mortality rates were 9% lower in vegetarians (Huang et al 2012). Kendler's (2003) book review of “Vegetarian nutrition” stated that five out of six studies showed people with low meat intakes having lower mortality rates. This does not mean that the same results will be found for vegan diets, although vegans were included amongst the vegetarians in the studies that were analysed. There are also other factors at play beyond diet that may influence the outcomes of these studies, such as smoking. Kendler (2003) mentioned that 'several' studies controlled for factors such as smoking, alcohol consumption and physical activity and still got similar results though. This means that there may, in fact, be a link. However, none seemed to go into processed foods versus whole foods, which may also have an effect.
A 2013 study by Rohrmann et al indicated that high red meat consumption and high processed meat consumption were both linked with higher mortality rates. However, consumption of chicken flesh seemed to have no such association. Links between red meat consumption and increased chance of death are not uncommon and are usually due to a higher chance of cardiovascular disease (heart problems), diabetes and cancer (Cross 2012; Pan et al 2012). By reducing the amount of red meat eaten however, it seems that these effects can be managed. There are differences in how different kinds of meat effect a person's health, which are also influenced by the amount of meat consumed. Then again, a study that involved 17, 611 people indicated no mortality rate association with meat consumption, no matter the type of meat (Kappeler, Eichholzer & Rohrmann 2013).
Another meta-analysis of a few studies indicated no or little difference between mortality rates of vegetarians (including vegans) and “health conscious” non-vegetarians (Ginter 2008). It was suggested that it was the higher consumption of antioxidants and healthy foods, along with a lower overall consumption, that was the cause for the longevity that is talked about (Ginter 2008). The study on Seventh-day Adventists (Fraser 1999) also leant towards this conclusion; “It is important to note that vegetarians may have lower disease risk because of their lack of meat consumption, but it is equally possible that this protection could be due to increased consumption of fruits, vegetables, or nuts. Upon multivariate analysis, the latter often appeared to be the case.”
Genetics may play a part in longevity (Perls & Terry 2003), as might calorie restriction (Omodei & Fontana 2011; Roth & Polotsky 2012). Yet another study has indicated that there are no significant lifestyle factor differences between people who live longer (BMI, exercise, alcohol consumption and calorie intake) (Rajpathak et al 2011).
The link between longevity and diet seems rather complex, with a variety of factors coming in to play. There is evidence to support the idea that vegetarians (and, maybe, vegans) live longer than non-vegetarians. There is, however, also a small amount of evidence of no difference between the groups. It seems that a variety of things, such as calorie restriction, genetics and the protective properties of plant-based foods, might be the reason that people on vegetarian or vegan diets appear to live longer. It may be that small amounts of unprocessed meat can be eaten with a healthy diet and lifestyle while maintaining the same length of life as a vegetarian or vegan with a healthy lifestyle. There seems to be some conflicting evidence, but also some strong trends. It is definitely an interesting subject and I look forward to reading more studies.
This article originally appeared on Keira's website.
Keira Edwards-Huolohan is a recent Sociology graduate. In 2013, Keira completed their Honours thesis, titled "Consumption ethics and poverty: What do vegans do to maintain a commitment to veganism when financially challenged?". They've been vegan since January 2010.
- Cross, A 2012, “Higher red meat consumption is associated with increased risk of all-cause, cardiovascular, and cancer mortality”, Evidence Based Nursing, vol. 15, no. 4, pp. 121 – 122.
- Fraser, G 1999, “Associations between diet and cancer, ischemic heart disease, and all-cause mortality in non-Hispanic white Californian Seventh-day Adventists”, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, vol. 70, no. 3, pp. 532s – 538s.
- Ginter, E 2008, “Vegetarian diets, chronic diseases and longevity”, Bratislava Medical Journal, vol. 109, no. 10, pp. 463 – 466.
- Huang, T, Yang, B, Zheng, J, Li, G, Wahlqvist, M & Li, D 2012, “Cardiovascular disease mortality and cancer incidence in vegetarians: A meta-analysis and systematic review”, Annals of Nutrition and Metabolism, vol. 60. no. 4, pp. 233 – 240.
- Kappeler, R, Eichholzer, M & Rohrmann, S 2013, “Meat consumption and diet quality and mortality in NHANES III”, European Journal of Clinical Nutrition, vol. 67, no. 6, pp. 598 – 606.
- Kendler, B 2003, “Vegetarian nutrition: Edited by Joan Sabat, Boca Raton: CRC Press, 2001, ISBN 0-8493-8508-3”, Reviewed in: Nutrition, vol. 19, no. 3, pp. 285 – 289.
- Omodei, D & Fontana, L 2011, “Calorie restriction and prevention of age-associated chronic disease”, FEBS Letters, vol. 585, no. 11, pp. 1537 – 1542.
- Pan, A, Sun, Q, Bernstein, A, Schulze, M, Manson, J, Stampfer, M, Willett, W & Hu, F 2012, “Red meat consumption and mortality: results from 2 prospective cohort studies”, Archives of Internal Medicine, vol. 172, no. 7, pp. 555 – 563.
- Perls, T & Terry, D 2003, “Genetics of exceptional longevity”, Experimental Gerontology, vol. 38, no. 7, pp. 725 – 730.
- Rajpathak, S, Liu, Y, Ben-David, O, Reddy, S, Atzmon, G, Crandall, J & Barzilai, N 2011, “Lifestyle factors of people with exceptional longevity”, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, vol. 59, no. 8, pp. 1509 – 1512.
- Rohrmann, S, Overvad, K, Bueno-de-Mesquita, H, Jakobsen, M, Egeberg, R, Tjønneland, A, Nailler, L, Boutron-Ruault, M, Clavel-Chapelon, F, Krogh, V, Palli, D, Panico, S, Tumino, R, Ricceri, F, Bergmann, M, Boeing, H, Li, K, Kaaks, R, Khaw, K, Wareham, N, Crowe, F, Key, T, Naska, A, Trichopoulou, A, Trichopoulos, D, Leenders, M, Peeters, P, Engeset, D, Parr, C, Skeie, G, Jakszyn, P, Sánchez, M, Huerta, J, Redondo, M, Barricarte, A, Amiano, P, Drake, I, Sonestedt, E, Hallmans, G, Johansson, I, Fedirko, V, Romieux, I, Ferrari, P, Norat, T, Vergnaud, A, Riboli, E & Linseisen, J 2013, “Meat consumption and mortality – results from the European Prospective Investigation into Cancer and Nutrition”, BMC Medicine, vol. 11, no. 1, pp. 63.
- Roth, L & Polotsky, A 2012, “Can we live longer by eating less? A review of caloric restriction and longevity”, Maturitas, vol. 71, no. 4, pp. 315 – 319.
|← Some impacts of climate change on specific industry sectors||Interview with Brian Evans: Vegan Exercise Enthusiast →|